A lot of my students enjoy reading graphic novels. I think there is some debate on whether graphic novels can be a legitimate literary text students should study. Although they contain far fewer words than prose, graphic novels are ripe with visual techniques that students learn to interpret. Furthermore, with the fewer words, students are required to fill in the blanks for themselves. My own students recognize that graphic novels and prose both employ description but that a graphic novel can be a great medium for story-showing instead of storytelling. I really enjoyed reading American Born Chinese. The author ties together three different story lines in a surprising way. Also, I think he addressed the issues of bullying, stereotypes and identity in a whole new way. Even if students aren't struggling with anti-Asian discrimination, they could be dealing with their sexuality or another aspect of their identities. Here are some ways I would use this text:
1. Students can study graphic novels as a medium to tell a story or narrative. First, as they read American Born Chinese they note one of the main story-lines and how the author develops the story through images. Students would write their own narratives and then create a graphic novel or comic for that narrative. Students are writing and thinking critically about which details are important and how a scene would really look. They are connecting the writing with images in their heads.
2. American Born Chinese is all about stereotypes, racism, discrimination and identity. Jin Wong realizes he is ostracized by his peers and by high school decides to change his identity. Through the three story lines, students can see various examples and effects stereotyping. In the Monkey King story, the monkey king turns violent when he is restricted from appreciation (and a good lunch) just because he is a monkey. He exchanges his kingdom and the love of his monkeys for power and an identity above the other deities. Young Wong's teachers are blatantly careless with their stereotypes. Wong's peers make a lot of assumptions about him and won't be his friend. Then he makes a couple friends (also Asian) who all suffer from various moments of bullying. Finally, Chin-Kee is the ultimate stereotype. He refers to himself in first person; he has terrible grammar; he eats cats and gizzards, he wears a top-knot and old fashion clothing. Probably the worst stereotype mentioned was when Chin-Kee told the girl he wanted to bind her feet and make her have his babies as if she was a possession. Students often struggle with taking their knowledge of the past (or just rumors) and applying them to the present. Some of my own students were calling Japanese people our enemies because of what happened in World War II. Then I asked them if they knew any Japanese people and if they were really like how they were thinking of them. Students can use their own experiences to understand this topic better and how to end it in their society.
3. Finally, I think it would be fun to look at the proverbs and wisdom present in this text. Chinese culture is often depicted as one rich in proverbs and parables. Students can read this graphic novel for the stories Yin's mother tells him and the monkey story-line. They can determine what the moral of the stores are and compare them to Western fables. In addition, students can write proverbs and fables of their own to demonstrate a point.
Saturday, November 23, 2013
Wednesday, November 20, 2013
"Night" by Elie Wiesel
Night is often
used in high schools, at least in Washington, as literature to help students
attain information and empathy toward the Holocaust. Any instruction on the
Holocaust must have a supportable rationale like students will learn about
discrimination, authority, and bystander syndrome as they study the Holocaust
and apply their knowledge to create solutions for their world today. Teachers
must be careful with how they teach their students about the Holocaust because
some students may become desensitized or, alternately, traumatized by this era
of hate and cruelty. In worst cases, students might blame the victims for their
weakness. Therefore, teachers use literature, fiction and non-fiction like Night, to introduce the human side of
the Holocaust to their students. Here are several strategies a teacher can use
with Night.
- Students
can study Night in literature
circles. In each group, students are in different roles that correspond
with each other to promote a deeper study of the text. One student may be
in charge of background research, another in charge of discussion
questions and yet another leading the bridge builder that connects the
book to other information they already know.
- Night is a memoir about one youth’s
experience with anti-Semitism, concentration camps and death. Throughout
this text, students can study how the author expresses his feelings (he
will never forgive himself for not protecting his father), deals with
violence and hunger, how his character changes and the historical context
of the story (this would fit in with a chronological study of the
Holocaust).
- Students
can also study the text for information about the Jewish faith. Elie’s
faith changes throughout the story from avid student to tormented
unbeliever. Although the focus would not be on how God failed the Jews, it
could focus on Elie’s personal evolution emotionally and spiritually.
Teachers beware of students over-identifying and becoming traumatized by
the text.
- Students
can study Night for instances of
discrimination, intolerance, violence, and hatred. The study should not
end there but build upon the students sense of social justice and how they
can change the world. Student can compare the Holocaust to instances of
genocide in Africa and hate crimes they have witnessed or heard about in
their own lives. This could lead to a project where students contribute to
the betterment of their community.
- Students
are studying human rights. Through a study of Night, students study Night
as a testimony of human rights activism. Students can also research
and study other human rights activists, connect the stories and present on
the information to their class. Then students create a plan on hose they
could become human rights activists.
Thursday, November 14, 2013
"Romeo and Juliet" by William Shakespeare
Romeo and Juliet was not my favorite text to read in high schools and it was not my favorite play to read in college. In high school, I did not struggle with the language but with the choices of the main characters. This text can be challenging for secondary students because 1. language 2. poetry and play writing 3. number of characters. With that said, there are several aspects of this books that are helpful to teach students new skills.
1. Translate into modern speak. Shakespeare invented a lot of new words. This play was written in modern English that is fairly unfamiliar to students. In order to get meaning out of the text, the teacher will need to do a bit of scaffolding on new vocabulary and how puns are used.Students work on interpreting and analyzing unfamiliar language to build on their own use of language and to understand complex language in their modern world. Students could translate a scene and then film it in the modern context.
2. Poetry. Shakespeare often employs soliloquies, sonnets and poetic elements in this play. Lines are in iambic pentameter. When students study Shakespeare's use of sonnets and write their own, they can organize their thoughts on a subject in a new way. Furthermore, students can use Shakespeare's use of metaphors to create metaphors that help them understand other subjects. Using metaphorical thinking and language can help students gain deeper understanding of their world. Additionally, a study of imagery in "Romeo and Juliet" can teach students how to be descriptive in their own writing.
3. "Romeo and Juliet" is a good play to study a time period. Written during the Elizabethan era, the play is set in Verona, Italy. Although the descriptions are not totally accurate to the area, students can compare the customs and concerns of the people with their own culture to learn more about the past. Moreover, students can study the tradition of theater in the culture. This is a tragic play though it was a romance. Students can examine what makes a tragedy, how the lovers acted and how those compare to their world.
4. Students can study "Romeo and Juliet" for theme. Overall the theme, or moral of the story, is that families should not feud, or people should not fight over nothing because the innocent pay for it. In addition, students can study the play to analyze how characters act and react to each other. How do the character's actions build on each other to continue the feud? Students can study the choices of the characters and decide whether they think the choices were wise and valid or not.
Overall, I would choose a Shakespearean comedy to teach. However, students can learn a lot (ethically) from tragedy and connect it to their own lives.
Thursday, November 7, 2013
"The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian" by Sherman Alexie
As a college student, I enjoyed reading Alexie's novel about a Spokane Indian boy facing challenges to make a better future for himself. This text offers us many aspects to study. Here are a few:
1. Culture & Diversity.
This novel is set on the Wellpinit Reservation, just north of Spokane. Some of Spokane's landmarks are mentioned. Arnold, the protagonist, ventures off to Reardan, a rural community, in order to get a better education. His sister marrieds a Flathead Indian and moves to Montana. For Washingtonian students, these details could make them want to read the book more and make them more connected to the text. I felt especially excited when Polson, MT was mentioned because I've been there. As a lesson, the teacher could focus on geography and the history of the tribe. Students can use the text to compare and contrast the two communities on their practices and living conditions. Furthermore, students can discuss how diversity is addressed in this book.
2. Identity.
In the beginning, Junior sees himself as a dirt poor Indian with "water on the brain." He has cerebral palsy and other issues that make him easy to pick on. But his teacher forces him to realize that his identity is not with his drunken tribe members. When Junior starts going to Reardan, he becomes Arnold: a confident student and capable athlete. Arnold builds a positive self view of himself and changes as a person a lot throughout the book. He struggles with being Indian on the reservation but "White" when he is in Reardan. Students can look at that transformation and analyze the resolution.
3. Coming-of-age & high school.
Arnold experiences a lot of hard things and a lot of great things in High School. He learns how to take care of himself and how to become a better student. He gains new perspectives about his tribe and makes decisions based on increasing wisdom.
4. Grief.
Arnold is faced with the death of his grandmother (killed by drunk driver), sister (burned to death while drunk, and Eugene (Dad's friend, shot while drunk). Arnold has to deal with the humor of his grandmother's funeral, the inappropriate reaction to his sister's death and his sadness at Eugene's death. Students can analyze Arnold's phases of grief and his thoughts on his family and tribe throughout. What does he think about alcohol? What are some of the tribe's traditions for deaths?
5. Challenges.
Arnold faces many challenges, many of which are listed above. He has problems and he finds solutions. He think he will be bullied, so he punches the cool jock first. He lost his best friend, so he keeps sending him questions and funny notes. He wants a better education, so he befriends the nerdy kid. He gets hurt in a basketball game, so he makes sure to beat them the next time. Arnold does not always know what to do but students can analyze the trouble he faces and how he always makes good. He makes more for himself and his future.
6. Poverty.
Arnold often talks about the poverty of the Spokane Indians. He also mentioned that there are some white people that are poorer than the Indians. Arnold struggles with having to walk to school, having dingy clothes, not being able to eat and not being able to pay for dates. Students can look at the causes and challenges poverty places on living and think of creative solutions to end poverty, at least for the tribe.
1. Culture & Diversity.
This novel is set on the Wellpinit Reservation, just north of Spokane. Some of Spokane's landmarks are mentioned. Arnold, the protagonist, ventures off to Reardan, a rural community, in order to get a better education. His sister marrieds a Flathead Indian and moves to Montana. For Washingtonian students, these details could make them want to read the book more and make them more connected to the text. I felt especially excited when Polson, MT was mentioned because I've been there. As a lesson, the teacher could focus on geography and the history of the tribe. Students can use the text to compare and contrast the two communities on their practices and living conditions. Furthermore, students can discuss how diversity is addressed in this book.
2. Identity.
In the beginning, Junior sees himself as a dirt poor Indian with "water on the brain." He has cerebral palsy and other issues that make him easy to pick on. But his teacher forces him to realize that his identity is not with his drunken tribe members. When Junior starts going to Reardan, he becomes Arnold: a confident student and capable athlete. Arnold builds a positive self view of himself and changes as a person a lot throughout the book. He struggles with being Indian on the reservation but "White" when he is in Reardan. Students can look at that transformation and analyze the resolution.
3. Coming-of-age & high school.
Arnold experiences a lot of hard things and a lot of great things in High School. He learns how to take care of himself and how to become a better student. He gains new perspectives about his tribe and makes decisions based on increasing wisdom.
4. Grief.
Arnold is faced with the death of his grandmother (killed by drunk driver), sister (burned to death while drunk, and Eugene (Dad's friend, shot while drunk). Arnold has to deal with the humor of his grandmother's funeral, the inappropriate reaction to his sister's death and his sadness at Eugene's death. Students can analyze Arnold's phases of grief and his thoughts on his family and tribe throughout. What does he think about alcohol? What are some of the tribe's traditions for deaths?
5. Challenges.
Arnold faces many challenges, many of which are listed above. He has problems and he finds solutions. He think he will be bullied, so he punches the cool jock first. He lost his best friend, so he keeps sending him questions and funny notes. He wants a better education, so he befriends the nerdy kid. He gets hurt in a basketball game, so he makes sure to beat them the next time. Arnold does not always know what to do but students can analyze the trouble he faces and how he always makes good. He makes more for himself and his future.
6. Poverty.
Arnold often talks about the poverty of the Spokane Indians. He also mentioned that there are some white people that are poorer than the Indians. Arnold struggles with having to walk to school, having dingy clothes, not being able to eat and not being able to pay for dates. Students can look at the causes and challenges poverty places on living and think of creative solutions to end poverty, at least for the tribe.
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)